| agost del 202312 d’ag. |  Premier League | Sheffield Utd 0–1 Crystal PalaceRegular Season - 1 | D |
| 18 d’ag. | Premier League | Nottingham Forest 2–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 2 | D |
| 27 d’ag. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–2 Manchester CityRegular Season - 3 | D |
| setembre del 202302 de set. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd2–2 EvertonRegular Season - 4 | E |
| 16 de set. | Premier League | Tottenham 2–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 5 | D |
| 24 de set. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–8 NewcastleRegular Season - 6 | D |
| 30 de set. | Premier League | West Ham 2–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 7 | D |
| octubre del 202307 d’oct. | Premier League | Fulham 3–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 8 | D |
| 21 d’oct. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–2 Manchester UnitedRegular Season - 9 | D |
| 28 d’oct. | Premier League | Arsenal 5–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 10 | D |
| novembre del 202304 de nov. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd2–1 WolvesRegular Season - 11 | V |
| 12 de nov. | Premier League | Brighton 1–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 12 | E |
| 25 de nov. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–3 BournemouthRegular Season - 13 | D |
| desembre del 202302 de des. | Premier League | Burnley 5–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 14 | D |
| 06 de des. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–2 LiverpoolRegular Season - 15 | D |
| 09 de des. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–0 BrentfordRegular Season - 16 | V |
| 16 de des. | Premier League | Chelsea 2–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 17 | D |
| 22 de des. | Premier League | Aston Villa 1–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 18 | E |
| 26 de des. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd2–3 LutonRegular Season - 19 | D |
| 30 de des. | Premier League | Manchester City2–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 20 | D |
| gener del 202421 de gen. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd2–2West HamRegular Season - 21 | E |
| 30 de gen. | Premier League | Crystal Palace3–2Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 22 | D |
| febrer del 202403 de febr. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–5Aston VillaRegular Season - 23 | D |
| 10 de febr. | Premier League | Luton1–3Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 24 | V |
| 18 de febr. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–5BrightonRegular Season - 25 | D |
| 25 de febr. | Premier League | Wolves1–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 26 | D |
| març del 202404 de març | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–6ArsenalRegular Season - 27 | D |
| 09 de març | Premier League | Bournemouth2–2Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 28 | E |
| 30 de març | Premier League | Sheffield Utd3–3FulhamRegular Season - 30 | E |
| abril del 202404 d’abr. | Premier League | Liverpool3–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 31 | D |
| 07 d’abr. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd2–2ChelseaRegular Season - 32 | E |
| 13 d’abr. | Premier League | Brentford2–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 33 | D |
| 20 d’abr. | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–4BurnleyRegular Season - 34 | D |
| 24 d’abr. | Premier League | Manchester United4–2Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 29 | D |
| 27 d’abr. | Premier League | Newcastle5–1Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 35 | D |
| maig del 202404 de maig | Premier League | Sheffield Utd1–3Nottingham ForestRegular Season - 36 | D |
| 11 de maig | Premier League | Everton1–0Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 37 | D |
| 19 de maig | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–3TottenhamRegular Season - 38 | D |
