| August 2023Aug 20 |  Serie A | Sassuolo 0–2 AtalantaRegular Season - 1 | W |
| Aug 26 | Serie A | Frosinone 2–1AtalantaRegular Season - 2 | L |
| September 2023Sep 02 | Serie A | Atalanta3–0 MonzaRegular Season - 3 | W |
| Sep 17 | Serie A | Fiorentina 3–2AtalantaRegular Season - 4 | L |
| Sep 21 |  Europa League | Atalanta2–0 Raków CzęstochowaGroup Stage - 1 | W |
| Sep 24 | Serie A | Atalanta2–0 CagliariRegular Season - 5 | W |
| Sep 27 | Serie A | Hellas Verona 0–1AtalantaRegular Season - 6 | W |
| October 2023Oct 01 | Serie A | Atalanta0–0 JuventusRegular Season - 7 | D |
| Oct 05 | Europa League | Sporting CP 1–2AtalantaGroup Stage - 2 | W |
| Oct 08 | Serie A | Lazio 3–2AtalantaRegular Season - 8 | L |
| Oct 22 | Serie A | Atalanta2–0 GenoaRegular Season - 9 | W |
| Oct 26 | Europa League | Sturm Graz 2–2AtalantaGroup Stage - 3 | D |
| Oct 30 | Serie A | Empoli 0–3AtalantaRegular Season - 10 | W |
| November 2023Nov 04 | Serie A | Atalanta1–2 InterRegular Season - 11 | L |
| Nov 09 | Europa League | Atalanta1–0Sturm GrazGroup Stage - 4 | W |
| Nov 12 | Serie A | Udinese 1–1AtalantaRegular Season - 12 | D |
| Nov 25 | Serie A | Atalanta1–2 NapoliRegular Season - 13 | L |
| Nov 30 | Europa League | Atalanta1–1Sporting CPGroup Stage - 5 | D |
| December 2023Dec 04 | Serie A | Torino 3–0AtalantaRegular Season - 14 | L |
| Dec 09 | Serie A | Atalanta3–2 AC MilanRegular Season - 15 | W |
| Dec 14 | Europa League | Raków Częstochowa0–4AtalantaGroup Stage - 6 | W |
| Dec 18 | Serie A | Atalanta4–1 SalernitanaRegular Season - 16 | W |
| Dec 23 | Serie A | Bologna 1–0AtalantaRegular Season - 17 | L |
| Dec 30 | Serie A | Atalanta1–0 LecceRegular Season - 18 | W |
| January 2024Jan 07 | Serie A | AS Roma 1–1AtalantaRegular Season - 19 | D |
| Jan 15 | Serie A | Atalanta5–0FrosinoneRegular Season - 20 | W |
| Jan 27 | Serie A | Atalanta2–0UdineseRegular Season - 22 | W |
| February 2024Feb 04 | Serie A | Atalanta3–1LazioRegular Season - 23 | W |
| Feb 11 | Serie A | Genoa1–4AtalantaRegular Season - 24 | W |
| Feb 17 | Serie A | Atalanta3–0SassuoloRegular Season - 25 | W |
| Feb 25 | Serie A | AC Milan1–1AtalantaRegular Season - 26 | D |
| Feb 28 | Serie A | Inter4–0AtalantaRegular Season - 21 | L |
| March 2024Mar 03 | Serie A | Atalanta1–2BolognaRegular Season - 27 | L |
| Mar 06 | Europa League | Sporting CP1–1AtalantaRound of 16 | D |
| Mar 10 | Serie A | Juventus2–2AtalantaRegular Season - 28 | D |
| Mar 14 | Europa League | Atalanta2–1Sporting CPRound of 16 | W |
| Mar 30 | Serie A | Napoli0–3AtalantaRegular Season - 30 | W |
| April 2024Apr 07 | Serie A | Cagliari2–1AtalantaRegular Season - 31 | L |
| Apr 11 | Europa League | Liverpool 0–3AtalantaQuarter-finals | W |
| Apr 15 | Serie A | Atalanta2–2Hellas VeronaRegular Season - 32 | D |
| Apr 18 | Europa League | Atalanta0–1LiverpoolQuarter-finals | L |
| Apr 21 | Serie A | Monza1–2AtalantaRegular Season - 33 | W |
| Apr 28 | Serie A | Atalanta2–0EmpoliRegular Season - 34 | W |
| May 2024May 02 | Europa League | Marseille 1–1AtalantaSemi-finals | D |
| May 06 | Serie A | Salernitana1–2AtalantaRegular Season - 35 | W |
| May 09 | Europa League | Atalanta3–0MarseilleSemi-finals | W |
| May 12 | Serie A | Atalanta2–1AS RomaRegular Season - 36 | W |
| May 18 | Serie A | Lecce0–2AtalantaRegular Season - 37 | W |
| May 22 | Europa League | Atalanta3–0 Bayer LeverkusenFinal | W |
| May 26 | Serie A | Atalanta3–0TorinoRegular Season - 38 | W |
| June 2024Jun 02 | Serie A | Atalanta2–3FiorentinaRegular Season - 29 | L |
