| August 2023Aug 12 |  Premier League | Brighton 4–1 LutonRegular Season - 1 | W |
| Aug 19 | Premier League | Wolves 1–4BrightonRegular Season - 2 | W |
| Aug 26 | Premier League | Brighton1–3 West HamRegular Season - 3 | L |
| September 2023Sep 02 | Premier League | Brighton3–1 NewcastleRegular Season - 4 | W |
| Sep 16 | Premier League | Manchester United 1–3BrightonRegular Season - 5 | W |
| Sep 21 |  Europa League | Brighton2–3 AEK Athens FCGroup Stage - 1 | L |
| Sep 24 | Premier League | Brighton3–1 BournemouthRegular Season - 6 | W |
| Sep 30 | Premier League | Aston Villa 6–1BrightonRegular Season - 7 | L |
| October 2023Oct 05 | Europa League | Marseille 2–2BrightonGroup Stage - 2 | D |
| Oct 08 | Premier League | Brighton2–2 LiverpoolRegular Season - 8 | D |
| Oct 21 | Premier League | Manchester City 2–1BrightonRegular Season - 9 | L |
| Oct 26 | Europa League | Brighton2–0 AjaxGroup Stage - 3 | W |
| Oct 29 | Premier League | Brighton1–1 FulhamRegular Season - 10 | D |
| November 2023Nov 04 | Premier League | Everton 1–1BrightonRegular Season - 11 | D |
| Nov 09 | Europa League | Ajax0–2BrightonGroup Stage - 4 | W |
| Nov 12 | Premier League | Brighton1–1 Sheffield UtdRegular Season - 12 | D |
| Nov 25 | Premier League | Nottingham Forest 2–3BrightonRegular Season - 13 | W |
| Nov 30 | Europa League | AEK Athens FC0–1BrightonGroup Stage - 5 | W |
| December 2023Dec 03 | Premier League | Chelsea 3–2BrightonRegular Season - 14 | L |
| Dec 06 | Premier League | Brighton2–1 BrentfordRegular Season - 15 | W |
| Dec 09 | Premier League | Brighton1–1 BurnleyRegular Season - 16 | D |
| Dec 14 | Europa League | Brighton1–0MarseilleGroup Stage - 6 | W |
| Dec 17 | Premier League | Arsenal 2–0BrightonRegular Season - 17 | L |
| Dec 21 | Premier League | Crystal Palace 1–1BrightonRegular Season - 18 | D |
| Dec 28 | Premier League | Brighton4–2 TottenhamRegular Season - 19 | W |
| January 2024Jan 02 | Premier League | West Ham0–0BrightonRegular Season - 20 | D |
| Jan 22 | Premier League | Brighton0–0WolvesRegular Season - 21 | D |
| Jan 30 | Premier League | Luton4–0BrightonRegular Season - 22 | L |
| February 2024Feb 03 | Premier League | Brighton4–1Crystal PalaceRegular Season - 23 | W |
| Feb 10 | Premier League | Tottenham2–1BrightonRegular Season - 24 | L |
| Feb 18 | Premier League | Sheffield Utd0–5BrightonRegular Season - 25 | W |
| Feb 24 | Premier League | Brighton1–1EvertonRegular Season - 26 | D |
| March 2024Mar 02 | Premier League | Fulham3–0BrightonRegular Season - 27 | L |
| Mar 07 | Europa League | AS Roma 4–0BrightonRound of 16 | L |
| Mar 10 | Premier League | Brighton1–0Nottingham ForestRegular Season - 28 | W |
| Mar 14 | Europa League | Brighton1–0AS RomaRound of 16 | W |
| Mar 31 | Premier League | Liverpool2–1BrightonRegular Season - 30 | L |
| April 2024Apr 03 | Premier League | Brentford0–0BrightonRegular Season - 31 | D |
| Apr 06 | Premier League | Brighton0–3ArsenalRegular Season - 32 | L |
| Apr 13 | Premier League | Burnley1–1BrightonRegular Season - 33 | D |
| Apr 25 | Premier League | Brighton0–4Manchester CityRegular Season - 29 | L |
| Apr 28 | Premier League | Bournemouth3–0BrightonRegular Season - 35 | L |
| May 2024May 05 | Premier League | Brighton1–0Aston VillaRegular Season - 36 | W |
| May 11 | Premier League | Newcastle1–1BrightonRegular Season - 37 | D |
| May 15 | Premier League | Brighton1–2ChelseaRegular Season - 34 | L |
| May 19 | Premier League | Brighton0–2Manchester UnitedRegular Season - 38 | L |
